AI failures · Fabricated content
Kruse v. Karlen — Missouri Court of Appeals Sanctions Self-Represented Appellant for AI-Fabricated Citations
Verified Checked against its sources on 3 sources quoted
- Where it happened
- Missouri, United States
- Organization
- N/A (individual self-represented litigant)
- Date
- February 13, 2024 (opinion filed)
- Function
- Legal
- Work stage
- Appellate brief drafting (by a hired online consultant, per the appellant)
- System
- Unspecified generative AI (per the appellant's account)
- Technology
- Generative AI
- Type of failure
- Fabricated content
- Caught by
- The opposing party, A court
Summary
Jonathan Karlen, a business owner representing himself in an appeal from an unpaid-wages judgment, filed an appellate brief in which only two of 24 case citations were genuine; he told the court an online consultant presenting as a California-licensed lawyer had prepared it, that he had not known the person would use AI, and that he had not meant to mislead the court. The Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District (No. ED111172), dismissed the appeal as frivolous and ordered him to pay $10,000 in damages toward the respondent's attorneys' fees.
Consequence
- Appeal dismissed as frivolous; appellant ordered to pay $10,000 in damages toward the respondent's attorneys' fees.
Who caught it The opposing party, A courtFound outside the organization
Analysis
What could have been done
Oversight of suppliers' AI use
Suppliers' use of AI is disclosed, contracted for and checked.
The appellant, a business owner representing himself, filed a brief that he said had been prepared by a hired online consultant presenting as a California-licensed lawyer, using generative AI by his account.
Checking AI output against its sources
Every factual element of AI output (citations, figures, quotations) is checked against its source before reliance.
Only two of the 24 case citations in the brief as filed were genuine.
What would likely have prevented it
- Before engaging an outside preparer for a filing or other document filed in one's own name, confirm any claimed professional licence with the body that issues it and ask whether and how AI tools will be used.
- Check the citations in delivered work against an authoritative source before signing or filing it, since the consequences of the filing fall on the filer.
What would likely have caught it earlier
- On receipt of outsourced work, check a sample of its citations; with only two of 24 genuine, almost any sample would likely have exposed the problem before the respondent's motion to strike did.
Key dates
- February 13, 2024Event
- October 16, 2026Checked against sources
- October 18, 2026Checked against sources
- October 21, 2026Checked against sources
- November 3, 2026Checked against sources
Developments are added when the record is reviewed. Next review: October 16, 2027.
Evidence
Each passage is quoted from its source. The record shows the date it was last checked.
-
First, the court dismissed his appeal. Then, deeming his appeal frivolous, it ordered him to pay $10,000 in damages towards his opponent’s attorneys’ fees.
Supports: Sanction: dismissal and $10,000 damages toward fees
He said he did not not know the person would use “artificial intelligence hallucinations” and denied any intent to mislead the court.
Supports: The appellant's account: an online consultant, AI use he did not know about, no intent to mislead
-
A three-judge panel for the Eastern District of the Missouri Court of Appeals determined that Jonathan Karlen, a business owner representing himself in an unpaid wages lawsuit in a state trial court, cited only two genuine legal precedents out of the 24 citations in his appeals brief.
Supports: Court, party, self-representation, 2 of 24 citations genuine
-
FILED: February 13, 2024
Supports: Opinion filing date
No. ED111172
Supports: Docket number
The appeal is dismissed. Appellant is ordered to pay $10,000 to Respondent in damages for filing a frivolous appeal.
Supports: Disposition: appeal dismissed; $10,000 in damages
Suggested citation. Eminence Scan, “Kruse v. Karlen — Missouri Court of Appeals Sanctions Self-Represented Appellant for AI-Fabricated Citations”, Eminence Growth Solutions, last verified November 3, 2026, https://eminencegrowthsolutions.com/tools/eminence-scan/record/fail-007/.
Using our research: you may read and quote Eminence Scan with credit to “Eminence Scan, Eminence Growth Solutions” and a link; all other rights reserved. Terms: Using our research.
Spotted an error, or a development we have missed? Report a correction. How we check records: research methodology.
