Cases and enforcement · Decided
GEMA v. OpenAI, Regional Court of Munich I (Landgericht München I), judgment of November 11, 2025, Az. 42 O 14139/24
Verified Checked against its sources on 3 sources quoted
- Where
- Germany
- Court or authority
- Germany – Landgericht München I (Regional Court of Munich I), 42nd Civil Chamber
- Status
- DECIDED AT FIRST INSTANCE NOVEMBER 11, 2025; CLAIMS SUBSTANTIALLY GRANTED; JUDGMENT NOT FINAL; APPEAL FILED AT THE HIGHER REGIONAL COURT OF MUNICH
- Date
- November 11, 2025 (first-instance judgment; court press release 11/2025)
- Case type
- Copyright
- Plaintiffs or complainants
- GEMA (Gesellschaft für musikalische Aufführungs- und mechanische Vervielfältigungsrechte), a collecting society
- Defendants
- Two companies of the OpenAI group (not named in the court's press release)
- Legal issues
- Whether memorization of song lyrics in a language model is a reproduction under Art. 2 InfoSoc Directive and section 16 UrhG; whether outputs reproducing lyrics infringe; scope of the text-and-data-mining exception (section 44b UrhG); responsibility of the model operator rather than users for outputs
Summary
On November 11, 2025, the copyright chamber of the Regional Court of Munich I ruled in a suit brought by GEMA, the German music collecting society, against two companies of the OpenAI group (case 42 O 14139/24). The suit concerned the lyrics of nine well-known German songwriters, which GEMA said were memorized in OpenAI's language models and reproduced largely verbatim in ChatGPT's answers to simple prompts. The court found that the lyrics were reproducibly contained in OpenAI's models 4 and 4o, and held that both the memorization in the models and the reproduction of the lyrics in outputs infringed the rights holders' exploitation rights. The OpenAI companies argued that their models do not store or copy specific training data and that users, not they, are responsible for outputs. The court held that the text-and-data-mining exception did not cover these copies and that OpenAI, not its users, was responsible for the outputs. The court substantially granted GEMA's claims for injunctive relief, information and damages, and dismissed a separate claim based on general personality rights over the misattribution of altered lyrics. The court stated that the judgment is not final, and an appeal to the Higher Regional Court of Munich has been filed; no appeal decision has been reported.
Key dates
- November 11, 2025Date
- October 30, 2026Checked against sources
- November 3, 2026Checked against sources
Developments are added when the record is reviewed. Next review: January 30, 2027.
Evidence
Each passage is quoted from its source. The record shows the date it was last checked.
-
Pressemitteilung 11 vom 11.11.2025
Supports: date: press release of November 11, 2025 (judgment announced "today")
42. Zivilkammer des Landgerichts München I hat mit Urteil vom heutigen Tag den von der GEMA gegen zwei Unternehmen der Unternehmensgruppe Open AI geltend gemachten Ansprüchen auf Unterlassungs-, Auskunfts- und Schadensersatz im Wesentlichen stattgegeben (Az. 42 O 14139/24).
Supports: court, parties (GEMA v. two OpenAI group companies), case number, outcome: injunction, information and damages claims substantially granted
Soweit die Klägerin darüber hinaus Ansprüche auf Grund einer Verletzung des allgemeinen Persönlichkeitsrechts wegen fehlerhafter Zuschreibung veränderter Liedtexte geltend gemacht hat, hat die Kammer die Klage abgewiesen.
Supports: personality-rights claim over misattributed altered lyrics dismissed
Das Urteil betrifft die Liedtexte neun bekannter deutscher Urheberinnen und Urheber
Supports: subject: lyrics of nine well-known German authors
Nach Überzeugung der Kammer seien die streitgegenständlichen Liedtexte reproduzierbar in den Sprachmodellen 4 und 4o der Beklagten enthalten
Supports: finding: lyrics reproducibly contained in models 4 and 4o
Sowohl durch die Memorisierung in den Sprachmodellen als auch durch die Wiedergabe der Liedtexte in den Outputs des Chatbot lägen Eingriffe in die urheberrechtlichen Verwertungsrechte vor. Diese seien nicht durch Schrankenbestimmungen, insbesondere die Schranke für das Text und Data Mining gedeckt.
Supports: holding: memorization and output reproduction both infringe; not covered by the text-and-data-mining exception
Hierfür seien die Beklagten und nicht die Nutzer verantwortlich
Supports: the defendants, not users, are responsible for the outputs
Das Urteil ist nicht rechtskräftig.
Supports: the judgment is not final
ihre Sprachmodelle speicherten oder kopierten keine spezifischen Trainingsdaten
Supports: the defendants' argument on training data
seien nicht die Beklagten, sondern der jeweilige Nutzer als Hersteller des Outputs für diese verantwortlich
Supports: the defendants' argument on responsibility for outputs
-
Gegen die Entscheidung des Landgerichts wurde Berufung beim OLG München eingelegt.
Supports: appeal filed at the Higher Regional Court of Munich
-
OpenAI is appealing a Munich court ruling last month that came down in favor of German music rights body GEMA.
Supports: OpenAI's appeal, reported December 10, 2025
Suggested citation. Eminence Scan, “GEMA v. OpenAI, Regional Court of Munich I (Landgericht München I), judgment of November 11, 2025, Az. 42 O 14139/24”, Eminence Growth Solutions, last verified November 3, 2026, https://eminencegrowthsolutions.com/tools/eminence-scan/record/case-060/.
Using our research: you may read and quote Eminence Scan with credit to “Eminence Scan, Eminence Growth Solutions” and a link; all other rights reserved. Terms: Using our research.
Spotted an error, or a development we have missed? Report a correction. How we check records: research methodology.
